Wednesday, November 2, 2011

An open letter from John C. Minder

The attempt of the majority of the Sarasota County Commission to circumvent voter-approved 8-year term limits has generated a lot of public discussion. Here's an open letter being circulated by John C. Minder of Minder & Associates Engineering Corporation addressed to the leaders of the Argus Foundation, Sarasota Chamber of Commerce, Gulf Coast Builders Exchange, Home Builders Association of Manatee and Sarasota and the Venice and Englewood Chambers of Commerce. Please keep in mind that for a local businessman to distribute such information requires some courage when you consider the power wielded by county commissioners:

Directors,

As a former member of the Gulf Coast Builders Exchange, a member of the Argus Foundation, a former member of the Sarasota County Chamber of Commerce, a member of the Home Builders Association of Manatee & Sarasota Counties, a potential member of the Venice Chamber of Commerce and a potential member of the Englewood Chamber of Commerce, I am requesting that your members vigorously oppose the proposed referendum proposed to be held on January 31, 2011, and protect my one vote as a taxpayer in Sarasota County who voted with the other 68 percent of the voters in Sarasota County in favor of eight year term limits in 1998.


The Commission should drop the referendum idea, wait for the Supreme Court and resign themselves to its decision. That is the right thing to do.
On Tuesday, October 25, 2011, the county attorney, a member of the Sarasota County Bar Association, brought up under County Attorney Reports the Board of County Commissioners previously requested legal request for him to investigate the legality of holding a referendum on January 31, 2011, to clarify the State Supreme Court’s decision, that hasn’t even been made yet, to extend the two year term limits voted in 1998 to three years and to negate the time already served by the existing County Commissioners so they can all run and attempt to be elected for another three terms!

Please see the video of the County Attorney’s Report on the morning of October 25, 2011, on the Sarasota County website. Commissioner Christine Robertson, a member of the Sarasota County Bar Association, led the discussion and made the motion to prepare an ordinance and to place the ordinance on the Agenda for a Public Hearing by the Board of County Commissioners. The motion was seconded by either Commissioner Carolyn Mason or Commissioner Nora Patterson I do not recall which one. Commissioner Jon Thaxton made no comments and Commissioner Joe Barbetta, a member of the Sarasota County Bar Association, vigorously opposed the motion and stated in so many words “The Commission should drop the referendum idea, wait for the Supreme Court and resign themselves to its decision. That is the right thing to do."

The vote was 4-1 to with the other four commissioners voting for the motion and Commissioner Joe Barbetta voting against the motion.

It is my professional opinion that this vote by the Board of County Commissions is a bad example and sends the wrong message to the county staff at a time when we are trying to put a stop to the corruption that has occurred in Sarasota County in the past.

Sincerely,

Minder & Associates Engineering Corporation
John C. Minder, PE, PSM

+++++

John C. Minder holds a Bachelor of Science Degree in Civil Engineering from the University of Illinois in 1964 and has done graduate work in Environmental Engineering at the Illinois Institue of Technology. He is a Professional Engineer with registration in Illinois, Florida, Indiana, Ohio, Michigan, and Wisconsin. He is also a Professional Surveyor and Mapper in Illinois and Florida. With over 45 years experience, Mr. Minder has been responsible for a variety of Civil Engineering projects throughout the Midwest, Southeast and Florida.

2 comments:

  1. Interesting reading from the Sarasota County Bar Association website, per John Minder:

    STANDARDS OF PROFESSIONALISM

    J. TRANSACTIONAL

    4. An attorney should not prepare a document that is intended to circumvent or violate applicable laws or rules.

    ReplyDelete
  2. More on-the-money commentary from John Minder, who attended the Nov. 21 emergency hearing where a judge struck down the county commission's misleading ballot language to ditch Sarasota's voter-approved 8-year term limits.

    +++++

    Commmissioners,

    I attended the Term Limits Hearing today in Judge Jack Schoonover’s Court Room and I couldn’t believe what I was seeing. Sarasota County Government had not only one but three attorney’s expending the tax payers dollars representing Sarasota County in defense of a request for a Declaratory Judgment filed by one attorney. One of the attorney’s was defending the eight year term limits passed by the Sarasota Voters in 1998 when the same Attorney representing Sarasota County’s on the eight year term limits was the same Attorney that recommended in 2005 not to appeal the Circuit Judge’s decision that eight year term limits was unconstitutional. The other Sarasota County Government Attorney was representing Sarasota County stating that if the State of Florida Supreme County ruled that the eight year term limits were constitutional then a referendum should be held on January 31, 2012 on the same day as the Republican Primary when the 57% of the Republican voters in Sarasota County would vote but the 43% of the Democrats in Sarasota County probably wouldn’t vote in or on the day of the Republican Primary or on a Referendum by Sarasota County to change the eight year term limits to twelve year term limits and make the 12 year term limits start on January 31, 2012 so all of the incumbent commissioners would start all over on the term limits.

    The other Attorney was the Sarasota County Attorney, who the tax payers are paying $205,000 a year plus benefits and he just sat there after he had selected two private Attorneys to represent Sarasota County. Do you think the tax payers of Sarasota County can really afford all of this expense so the incumbent County Commissioners will not be bound by eight year term limits and each of them can remain County Commissioners for at least 12 more years?

    Minder & Associates Engineering Corporation
    John C. Minder, PE, PSM

    ReplyDelete